How Jerry Falwell Helped Build the Gay Rights Movement

By: Lowell
Published On: 5/19/2007 6:48:32 AM

I love this article, if for no other reason than it demonstrates how wonderfully complex our world is.  In this case, the authors of "The Legacy of Falwell's Bully Pulpit" demonstrate how even the actions of an intolerant, bigoted person can sometimes backfire and result in the exact opposite of what that person intended.  Thus:

Gay advocates, gradually realizing that they could not beat [Jerry Falwell] through vehemence alone, learned to seek out religious spokespeople, cultivate multiracial alliances and trade diatribe for discipline so as to use Falwell's polarizing statements to gain moderate supporters.

What's amazing is that, all in all, gay rights probably moved forward a lot faster over the past couple of decades due to the absurd, almost cartoonish hostility emanating from the Jerry Falwells of the world.  For instance, when Falwell said that "so-called gay folks would just as soon kill you as look at you," that gays were "after my children and your children," ane that AIDS is "God's punishment for homosexuals," it might have had successful in the very short-term, but in the longer run it almost certainly led to a backlash by more tolerant Americans.  As the authors of the Washington Post article explain:

By speaking about gay people as outsiders, and even as disease-bearing strangers, he forced many Christians to look honestly at their congregations and reexamine the premise of their faith. By casting gays as threats to the survival of families, he forced parents, siblings and relatives of all kinds to reassess what values bind them together and how they care for one another. By approaching the law, especially in privacy and civil rights, as a battleground for competing visions of righteousness, he goaded a generation of scholars and activists to talk not simply in terms of precedents and entitlements but ever more persuasively in terms of conscience, morality and fairness.

To put it in Hegelian terms, Falwell's thesis - that gays are evil - led to an antithesis - a powerful gay rights movement - which ultimately resulted in a synthesis - American tolerance of homosexuals, even civil unions and gay marriage.  Certainly not the results Jerry Falwell wanted when he screamed about gays coming to convert our children to their "lifestyle."  Or to put it in (pop) theological terms, perhaps it's simply that "God works in mysterious ways!" :)


Comments



Good Bye and Good Ridence (Gordie - 5/19/2007 8:09:36 AM)
No longer being a church going religous person, but a firm believer in the Bible and the Teachings of Christ as a guidence of how one should live their life, I despise anyone like Gerry Falwell who took the passages they wanted and pushed agendas to further enhance their own existance.

But as this article certainly demonstrates the teaching in the Bible, "Out of Evil There will be Goodness", certainly portrays how the Power in this Universe Governs and Guides.



today is their graduation (martha - 5/19/2007 9:31:20 AM)
I just got back from my local Starbucks and the LU graduates, family and some faculty were rushing in and out for their coffee fixes before heading to "the mountain" to graduate.My friend had to fuss at me for looking w/ disdain at them and reminded me that I shouldn't HATE them...they are just kids.

It's sort of hard not to detest them. The whole rise of Falwell, LU, Thomas Road Baptist Church and it's subsequent influx of religious right followers to Lynchburg has changed the city forever ( for the worse I think).

Fred Phelps ( God hates fags) will be here at Jerry's funeral to protest Jerry since he professed his love for everyone ( including gays) and one of LU's professors wrote a column in The News and Advance about Phelps today...interesting article for sure.

The newspaper has been glowing about all the good Jerry has done. Very little if any negative comments. I for one am just waiting for the whole thing to die down. I am sick of Jerry...sick of him. I am not happy when anyone dies but the long, drawn out eulogies, funeral, graduation and NOW an eternal flame that will be built on the mountain is just overwhelming.

Bury him and move on.



Bill Maher on Jerry Falwell (Lowell - 5/19/2007 11:13:44 AM)

Starting at about 2:18.  Warning: not for the "politically correct," especially the easily offended right wing "politically correct."



Leonard Pitts (Susan P. - 5/19/2007 1:25:59 PM)
Leonard Pitts had a wonderful column about Jerry Falwell yesterday:
http://www.miamihera...
What a great writer and thinker.


he met w/ them but.... (martha - 5/19/2007 1:46:30 PM)
They were supposed to all get together to eat lunch after their meeting but Falwell and his people would not "break bread" w/ the Soulforce folks. I suppose you aren't supposed to eat w/ sinners.

Al Mr. Pitts said it was his finest hour...but the entire story is not well known.



Right (Susan P. - 5/19/2007 2:42:58 PM)
As we know, Jesus refused to break bread with sinners.  Oh, wait....