Richmond heading for more retail overbuild

By: Terry85
Published On: 12/13/2006 12:42:57 AM

Can we please get some restraint on the ridiculous, unnecessary sprawl, and destruction of the environment surrounding the city of Richmond? I heard the other day from a friend that there are plans to build two new malls in the suburbs of Richmond, adding to the already incredibly over saturated retail market here.

I held off on writing about it because I wasn't sure how much (if any) truth there was behind it. However, tonight on the local CBS affiliate, WTVR CBS 6 it was confirmed that there is indeed a plan to build two new malls in the area. They showed a brief interview with a representative for The Richmond Retail Merchants Association (an advocate for the Richmond retail community) who is even opposed to the insane plan, pointing out this interesting (and disturbing) fact:

In the United States, on average, there is about 20 square feet of retail space per person. The average for the Richmond metro area is OVER tripled that, at about 67 square FEET OF RETAIL SPACE FOR EVERY MAN, WOMAN, AND CHILD!

I held off on writing about it because I wasn't sure how much (if any) truth there was behind it. However, tonight on the local CBS affiliate, WTVR CBS 6 it was confirmed that there is indeed a plan to build two new malls in the area. They showed a brief interview with a representative for The Richmond Retail Merchants Association (an advocate for the Richmond retail community) who is even opposed to the insane plan, pointing out this interesting (and disturbing) fact:

In the United States, on average, there is about 20 square feet of retail space per person. The average for the Richmond metro area is OVER tripled that, at about 67 square FEET OF RETAIL SPACE FOR EVERY MAN, WOMAN, AND CHILD!

This is absurd, especially since walking around local malls (on the rare occasion that I go to them), makes me believe that some retailers aren't having an easy time of things! It seems like many stores (especially the smaller ones) do not stay open long, and at Short Pump Town Center (despite their blatant LIE claiming otherwise) I can't help but notice there are A LOT OF EMPTY SUITES, from where a business has packed up and left the mall (presumably due to a lack of business).

While SOME growth clearly CAN be a good thing, UNNECESSARY GROWTH NEVER IS! Richmond CANNOT support all of this retail. Not only that, but when either new homes, or retail centers are thrown up hastily, and/or in areas where they are not needed, in time, the building becomes empty, or unkempt, and the area becomes essentially a SLUM, which will no doubt happen to Short Pump, and other suburbs within the next 10 years.

Besides that, there is of course the fact that such massive sprawl is extremely detrimental to the environment.

I realize that the Richmond metro area is sort of an exception to the general rule that the city be the CENTER of a region, because most everything here is focused on our over sized suburbs (however, 'downtown' Richmond IS growing rapidly with over 2 dozen construction projects in the works, and the wonderful expansion to the VCU campus), BUT, we seriously need to get some restraint on all of the excessive, atrocious looking, and unnecessary sprawl of the suburbs.


Comments



UGH. (phriendlyjaime - 12/13/2006 10:11:34 AM)
I don't know what's worse-crossing the river to head into the bowels of nasty suburb central, otherwise known as "the Southside" or heading out to Short Pump, which is a bastion of greed and gluttony.

Good work, btw.



I'm With You (mmc0412 - 12/13/2006 2:30:39 PM)
Jaime.  Can't stand to go out to Short Pump and never could stand going to Southside!  We tried to fight development in our west end neighborhood which destroyed some wetlands, but we failed.  That darned Henrico is too property tax hungry!


Well (DukieDem - 12/13/2006 3:21:56 PM)
I'm gonna let my yuppie in training DLC side come out and say that Short Pump is awesome and there's no way in hell it'll be a slum in 10 years. I don't think we need two new malls but I for one love everything about our suburbs (except the way they vote, although Henrico isn't bad).


Oh no? (Terry85 - 12/13/2006 4:34:55 PM)
It's a natural cycle, ESPECIALLY when you saturate the retail market so much that retailers can't make any profit.  The *fact* is that the high end retailers that have come down here from the North forgot one thing: MOST PEOPLE IN RICHMOND CANNOT AFFORD THAT STUFF.  Lord + Taylor wised up and BACKED OUT before their wing of S.P. mall was even added on!!!  The older suburbs are becoming 'slums' and it won't be long before there is another "Short Pump" further out from the city, and Short Pump becomes a slum itself.


watch it now... (CommonSense - 12/13/2006 9:09:31 PM)
I lived in "southside" from 1963 to 1996.
I watched Southside Plaza die and become a place I wouldn't even go in the daytime...on a week-day.
I watched Midlothian Pike and Hull Steet Road blossom and die as businesses pushed west.
I watched Forest Hill Avenue and Bon Air become bottlenecks to negotiate to get somewhere else.
I watched as they filled in the blanks all the way to Brandermill and Midlothian and beyond.
I moved from Chesterfield to Powhatan and wanted to put up a gate.
I watched them in my rear view mirror follow me all the way home.
Then I left.
Moved to 30 acres in Nelson.
Am I safe?  Probably not. Madison Heights is creeping up from Lynchburg and Albemarle is starting to spread down 29South. We won't even discuss 29North.

It is always the same. Push out, build, bloom, wither and die and then push out further leaving trash behind.
You really think it can't happen to Short Pump?
Go visit Southside Plaza. Chippenham Mall. Regency Mall. Azalea Mall (ok, that one's not southside).  Many Malls...



Good points.. (Terry85 - 12/13/2006 11:18:04 PM)
Common Sense, excellent points.  Thank you!

Virginia, once again, needs to get a grip, or years and years from now we're going to have nothing but 1000's of miles of polluted wasteland.



Charlottesville-Albemarle Growth (uva08 - 12/14/2006 12:12:02 AM)
I have been wondering what effects (if any) the recent explosion in growth in the Charlottesville-Albemarle (Chalbemarle) will have on sales in Short Pump.  Just about everyone I know travels down there regularly to shop but now we have several new developments in the pipeline that are slated to be completed over the next couple of years.  There is the massive Albemarle Place (www.albemarleplace.com) which is supposed to rival shopping areas in NOVA.  Then there are Hollymead Town Center Phase II, North Pointe, Gazebo Plaza, Old Trail, Crozet Station, Avon Park, Rivanna Village, Belvedere, the sprawl in Zion Crossroads, the several shopping centers going up in Greene County.... The list goes on and on. I am willing to bet that five years from now traveling outside of Charlottesville for anything won't be necessary.

Commonsense... What part of Nelson do you live in?  My father just bought a place out there not to long around Lovingston.  It's a great area, easy commute to Charlottesville, and the housing cost are relatively low.  I think it will be the next frontier in Charlottesville growth.  I am just waiting for a Lake Monticello style development to be announced for that county. 



29North (CommonSense - 12/14/2006 8:10:33 AM)
was difficult to begin with, and now is pretty much an impossible nightmare. Shades of Midlothian Turnpike. Or Broad Street.
I don't think I ever really knew what "rape of the land" meant until they started on Hollymead. I had never seen a sinkhole before either.

We already have a "Lake Monticello", it is called Wintergreen/Stony Point......

I can only hope that growth will be somewhat slower, at least in the west where I am due to vertical difficulties, but don't really hold out much hope for the valleys.

Problem is that not everyone can afford to live in Charlottesville. Affordable housing is a joke. And yes, what is creeping in from the south and east is only surpassed by what we are doing to ourselves here. Richmond is not alone in this rampant need and we won't be far behind if we don't take a hard look now.



Short Pump (Terry85 - 12/14/2006 9:57:00 PM)
I went out to that hellhole Short Pump today (only because it was the only place we could find a decent xmas tree), and saw where they had cleared all the land across from BestBuy...it looked like a DESERT out there because they had cleared all the trees!  It's so sad...