Jim Webb: Passion Please. You are right but weak in debate/campaigining.

By: TexasMacaca
Published On: 10/12/2006 12:31:30 PM

I saw the last webb-Allen debate and I was diasappointed. There is so much to say and so many obvious things; but I saw no passion or go for the kill from Webb. Intellectual talk doesn't help with stupid Americans. They need simple and one line catch sentences and they need you to repeat.

Think of Bill Clinton's quote - Americans will prefer "Strong and wrong to weak and right"

Webb was right and weak in that debate. Against Allen, that doesn't cut it. You got to get in the trenches and get in hand to hand combat. Steve Jarding did that early on and he dissapeared all of a sudden.


Comments



Where's the Problem (Catzmaw - 10/12/2006 11:51:58 PM)
Mr. Webb is no rhetorical barnburner, but generally he does a pretty good job of getting his ideas across.  Sound bites from him would probably sound too rehearsed and trite, just as they already do from Allen.  You could almost see Allen touching on his cues from his debate prep -- "sound bite, sincere smile at the camera, look relaxed, another sound bite about about Webb doing the bidding of Hillary, Kerry, and Kennedy -- do it accusatorily, George, make it sound sincere ..."  The only part Allen and company hadn't rehearsed, the Senkaku Islands, left him utterly flatfooted. 

Mr. Webb has spent his entire civilian life as a writer.  He's a thinker, but there is a certain glibness which must be developed to make a really good public speaker or debater.  One has to snatch the thread of the idea out of the air and weave an answer around it, all while adjusting to the audience.  It takes a lot of practice. Allen is often described as an experienced debater, but I sense no originality or spontaneity in him.  He's not a real debater.  He can't handle questions coming out of left field and he often does not address the question but instead plugs in the closest canned answer.  Most baby lawyers would probably be able to kick his butt in a courtroom.