Programmers Guild Urges Virginians to Vote for Jim Webb, Says Miller is a "Job Killer"

By: Lowell
Published On: 6/3/2006 6:26:59 PM

The following is from the Programmers Guild, an organization which "advances the interests of technical and professional workers in information technology (IT) fields" (bolding added for emphasis):

In response to the Harris Miller campaign,

Harris Miller was coined the "Anti-Christ of Outsourcing" by the AFL-CIO because of his work as an industry lobbyist and president of the ITAA, the political arm of the world's largest technology companies. While a lobbyist, Miller testified in front of Congress that Americans did not have the skills needed to fill technology jobs, and requested an increase in the H-1b visa cap, which allows foreign guest workers to work up to six years in the United States.

The H-1b visa program enables companies to replace American workers with foreign guest workers who are paid on average $13,000 a year less than their American counterparts, and also prevents the guest workers from changing jobs if they are mistreated by their employers. This visa program has become an indentured servant program designed as a labor subsidy for greedy corporations. When IT professionals and pro-immigrant groups asked for Congress to fix the program, Harris Miller opposed us.

In 2001, American software professionals lost 139,000 jobs while the government approved 110,713 H-1b visas in computer occupations. While Americans IT workers were losing jobs and being permanently replaced, Harris Miller was a busy bee working hard to prevent the H-1b visa cap from falling back to historical levels.

In addition to supporting a modern day form of indentured servitude, Miller fought to make outsourcing American jobs even more lucrative for his corporate masters. In his misguided logic, Miller believes that allowing American jobs to be outsourced will create more jobs in the United States. Since the year 2000 the Department of Labor has reduced ten-year job growth projections in Information Technology by over one million jobs. So much for the economic theories of Harris Miller. Any way you look at it, Harris Miller is a job killer.

The Programmers Guild opposes Harris Miller and urges voters to support Jim Webb in the Democratic primaries on June 13th.  Jim Webb has promised to be a champion of American workers and will oppose the outsourcing of American jobs.

Roy Lawson
Programmers Guild
Director



Comments



Distriution of this? (Teddy - 6/3/2006 6:40:37 PM)
Great summary of Miller's anti-labor record, only--- is it sent to newspapers and other media, or just to members of the Guild? If we have the e-mail addresses of all those foolish machine Dems who back Miller, I suggest some public-spirited person e-mail the complete text to as many of them as can be reached.


Good idea to get this out... (Lowell - 6/3/2006 6:48:10 PM)
See here and here for the e-mail addresses of Virginia Democratic Party committee chairs. 


I am told that the letter has been sent. (DemTilDeath - 6/3/2006 10:05:24 PM)
I am also told that it is making waves and some people are very angry to have received it.

Ah well...



Why? (TurnVirginiaBlue - 6/3/2006 10:39:02 PM)
Why are they upset?  Most of this information is well documented by larger professional societies and labor organizations.


Because they don't want to hear the truth (DemTilDeath - 6/3/2006 10:47:24 PM)
The people who have decided to support Miller don't want to hear what Harris Miller has done.  They are the Virginia Democratic Party establishment that the mainstream media has been talking about.  They are the ones who can't get past Webb's supporting Allen.  They like the idea of a former Democratic Committee chair getting the nomination because they, themselves, are Democratic Committee chairs. 

But not all of the chairs are for Miller.  Maybe not even most.  But the ones who have decided to support are not going to like to see a message in their inbox containing this letter.  And that's an understatement.



ah (TurnVirginiaBlue - 6/3/2006 11:00:25 PM)
They need to get out more what can I say.


Shame on any Democratic Committee chairs who do not already know Millers sordid past... (Loudoun County Dem - 6/4/2006 12:40:30 AM)
I can understand the average voter not paying close attention at this point (disappointing, but I understand) BUT any active Democrats and ESPECIALLY CHAIRS should have learned this weeks ago.

When I first learned that Miller was running for the Democratic nomination a simple Google search on him unveiled so much damning anti-labor and anti-voter evidence that I assumed I had the wrong Harris Miller.

As I see it, The Democratic party nominating a candidate with such an overwhelming anti-labor, union busting, anti-voter history should be as absurd as the republicans nominating an athiest, pro-gay, abortion provider... it would be an abomination to the bedrock principles of the party and it just SHOULD NOT HAPPEN!!!



It's cowardly, and ... (Kathy Gerber - 6/4/2006 2:55:20 AM)
It's not "should be as absurd" it IS as absurd.

And they are certainly aware of it.  I wonder if that's why all of the feelers about supporting whichever Dem wins the primary are floating about. Perhaps they want to get a loss estimate? 

Loyalty is a two-way street.

Furthermore, we have two candidates who have at times in their history given support to another party (Republicans).  One of them has reasons, and one has excuses.  One of them has been open about it, and one of them has been deceptive. 

The list goes on.  The choice is obvious. 



Very good (Arturo - 6/3/2006 11:22:22 PM)
I am glad that some Virginia Democrats are upset that they received this letter.  Millions of former middle class Americans are upset too, that they lost their jobs under a misguided foreign visa program. Miller's behavior has been undemocratic and he does not deserve to be our senator.


Agreed. (DemTilDeath - 6/3/2006 6:50:07 PM)
My understanding is that this letter is going to newspapers.  But to make sure it gets distributed widely, everyone needs to send it out. 

Excellent letter.



This letter (Arturo - 6/3/2006 11:38:05 PM)
should also be sent to the entire Alexandria City Council who endorsed Henry, I mean Harris "Job Outsourcer" Miller. And to Joe Cobbe, the mayor of Martinsville, who endorsed him also.  Martinsville is seeing a mass exodus of people who cannot find jobs.  The mayor needs to know the truth about Miller. 


nice summary (TurnVirginiaBlue - 6/3/2006 6:50:05 PM)
The Programmer's Guild really tracks on the ITAA because software programmers are the number one target for labor arbitrage.

Very nice summary.



Another Labor Nail in Miller's Coffin (loboforestal - 6/3/2006 7:01:48 PM)
The Programmer's Guild, though apparently not "legally" a union is a union in the same sense that the American Medical Association is [correct me if I'm wrong]. They work to influence laws affecting many of today's modern working Joes.
Big Business and Big Bucks don't get the freehand that Harris Miller would like with guys like these on watch.  They also oppose overreaching intellectual property laws and anti-competitive measures by businesses.  They are long time allies with many vociferious critics of Harris Miller's abusive legislative record.  They are the flip side of the more conservative critics of Miller who emphasize that Miller's policies are "unfair subsidies" for the very wealthiest members of our society.

Harris stepped on some toes on his tour of Captiol Hill, Bangalore and K-Steet.  Lotta folks remembers the deals he made and phony whitepapers and the money he waved to  buy some bad public policy.  Looks like another punch in the gut for poor old Harris from labor.



Old Programmer's Guild Article on Wired ... (loboforestal - 6/3/2006 7:27:12 PM)
http://www.wired.com/news/business/0,1367,44246,00.html?tw=wn_story_related

Despite this tough talk, the guild won't get far, predicts Harris Miller, president of the Information Technology Association of America, a trade group that includes IBM, Intel and Microsoft.



yet another piece of evidence (TurnVirginiaBlue - 6/3/2006 7:31:40 PM)
That the claim the bloggers started blasting Miller in response to this campaign is 100% false.  The various groups have been blasting the ITAA and Miller for years...and because they write software, many of them, they are online.


Well, some Professor's been bashing him for years on email ... (loboforestal - 6/3/2006 8:28:12 PM)
Check out Norm Matloff's emails from way back when many of which take a firm aim at Mr. Miller :

http://www.google.com/search?q=%22harris+miller%22+site:http://heather.cs.ucdavis.edu/Archive/&hl=en&lr=&start=0&sa=N

here too: http://www.google.com/search?q=%22ITAA%22+site:http://heather.cs.ucdavis.edu/Archive/&hl=en&lr=&start=20&sa=N

Lots of stuff detailing Harris Miller and the ITAA's collusion with his Republican, big business and Cato Institute buddies.  Combined with his "attack Iraq" stance a lot of what Miller stands for represents what might be called "neoconservatism".

The eloquent and meticulous Norm Matloff has lead the charge against Mr. Miller for years.

As befitting a respected academic researcher, Dr. Matloff's work is very careful. 



nice job (teacherken - 6/3/2006 10:30:58 PM)
although I have to point out I was seeing this in data processing back in the 1970's in Philadelphia and some in the 80's around DC, when companies would bring in batches of overseas programmers and put them into group houses and pay them about 1/3 of what they were paying American workers.

But I also note that in the 1960's when I was part of a very small outfit, we share office space with a guy who ran a keypunching service (yes, I go back that far in dp -- didn't start to switch to education until 1994 when I left to do an MAT) for companies in NY.  The deal was if you gave him your document by 4 PM, you would get back keyed and verified cards by 2 PM the next day. He put the documents on a plane to Haiti, where he was paying around $.15 an hour for workeers on a 10 hour overnight shift.  Even after he paid for the transportation of the documents down (cheap) and cards back (quite a bit bulkier), paid his courier and the bribes he was paying the Haitians (and in those days it was not against US law to bribe foreign officials) and paid his labor, he was making a very comfortable (almost 6 figures) income for himself without having to do much except look for more clients.

All his clients cared was that they got accurate keypunching almost as fast as doing it in-house, and they really didn't care about the conditions under which his workers operated.  The only thing that puzzled me was how he could be sure of a constant supply of electricity for his machines given the ppor quality of the Haitian grid system.  I think that was part of the reason for the bribes, but he never explained it all.



Great (Nichole - 6/3/2006 9:09:52 PM)
I feel like this is a wonderful statement (not for Miller :)).

People see what he did, especially people from the inside. He can deny it til he is blue in the face, but the facts are the facts.

If he had done a great job, and saved jobs and created them as he states he has...... they would be PRAISING him.

Obviously that is not the case!



RE: More great news (JPTERP - 6/4/2006 2:50:55 AM)
Do you think this will this translate into any financial or logistical support for the campaign? 


COMMENT HIDDEN (VADem4Ever - 6/5/2006 2:13:55 AM)


Actually, my understanding is that (Lowell - 6/5/2006 8:06:36 AM)
the Programmers' Guild is a 501(c)4.  I'll let the tax lawyers explain to me what that one means exactly! :)


This is complete bull (PaulVa - 6/5/2006 12:02:25 PM)
Something I would expect from someone called VAGOP4Ever


IRS REGULATIONS VIOLATED BY GUILD (VADem4Ever - 6/5/2006 10:12:39 AM)
Lowell,

The bylaws for the Programmers Guild on its website notes that it operates as a tax-exempt 501(c)3 corporation.  It is not a 501(c)4 as you suggested in your earlier posting.

IRS regulations specifically prohibit such non-profits from engaging in political activity of any kind on behalf of a candidate and allow only limited lobbying.

Here is the language from the IRS website:

"Under the Internal Revenue Code, all section 501(c)(3) organizations are absolutely prohibited from directly or indirectly participating in, or intervening in, any political campaign on behalf of (or in opposition to) any candidate for elective public office.  Contributions to political campaign funds or public statements of position (verbal or written) made on behalf of the organization in favor of or in opposition to any candidate for public office clearly violate the prohibition against political campaign activity.  Violation of this prohibition may result in denial or revocation of tax-exempt status and the imposition of certain excise tax."

I think someone who is coordinating this Programmers Guild endorsement like you or Tech Guy need to communicate to these folks that they are violating the law.

As I said earlier, it doesn't help Jim Webb or the Democratic Party to be associated with illegal activity like this.



Accusation Against the Guild: NOT TRUE (jmiano - 6/5/2006 11:11:18 AM)
The Programmers Guild is not 501(c)(3) corporation. It has never been a 501(c)(3) corporation. It has never solicited money tax deductable contributions as a 501(c)(3) corporation.

If there be some reference on the web site to the Guild being a 501(c)(3) [something I cannot find through Google], it is a typographical error.

I personally made the corporate filings and the documentation is next to me.

From the tone and need to repeat this accusation, I know this statement will never convince the original poster. For the rest of you, I hope the straight facts from the original source will put this nonsense to rest.

John Miano, J.D.



Interesting (PaulVa - 6/5/2006 8:42:30 PM)
I wonder if the poster is as vigilant about the frequent IRS violations from some of the right wing groups?


John Miano's Congressional Testimony (Info_Tech_Guy - 6/5/2006 10:39:34 AM)
John Miano, a former president of the Programmer's Guild recently testified before Congress.

I have added a link to his testimony, among others, on The Modern Patriot blog site (upper right under the "LINKS" section)

Here's a direct link:

http://judiciary.house.gov/media/pdfs/miano033006.pdf

Some interesting points John makes which are totally at odds with the claims made by Harris Miller and the ITAA...
· I have personally seen Americans being fired and replaced by lower-paid workers on H-1B visas.
· I have personally seen the H-1B program used to import large numbers of workers with limited skills who required extensive on-the-job training.
· I have personally seen resumés for H-1B workers with U.S. experience that would immediately be rejected had they been from Americans.
· I have personally seen resumés for H-1B workers that immediately suggested the education and experience listed were fraudulent.