Live Blog with Sen. Mary Margaret Whipple, Wednesday 3 PM

By: Lowell
Published On: 3/25/2008 11:37:41 AM

Virginia Senate Democratic Caucus Chair Mary Margaret Whipple will be live blogging here at RK on Wednesday, March 26th at 3 p.m.  Please feel free to leave your questions/comments in the thread below.  Thanks.

Senator Whipple will be taking questions Wednesday regarding the Virginia General Assembly session, the special session to deal with the bond package and transportation.

Elected to the Virginia State Senate in 1995, Whipple serves as the chair of the Senate Democratic Caucus, making her the first woman to hold a leadership position in the Virginia General Assembly.  She represents the 31st Senate District, which includes parts of Arlington County, Falls Church and Fairfax County.  



Comments



I guess I want to start by saying thanks... (ericy - 3/25/2008 11:44:08 AM)

for taking the lead on issues like Peak Oil.  I saw the presentation she gave at the ASPO conference in Houston last year (via the DVD set, not in person).  It sometimes is disheartening to see society in a headlong rush to try and consume ever more stuff, and it is refreshing to hear a voice of sanity out there.


Thanks for having me... (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:02:36 PM)

Thank you for inviting me to be with you this afternoon on Raising Kaine.

First of all, thank you so much for all you did to help us take back the Senate.

Gaining the majority in the Senate couldn't have come at a better time because we will now have that Democratic majority when the time comes for redistricting in 2011.

Un our first session in the majority we had a lot of success: reformed Virginia's mental health sysem, repealed the abusive driver fees, made new investments in Pre-K, reformed election and campaign procedures, and add new protections for women who are victims of abuse.

Maybe most importantly, our caucus had a seat at the table during the budget negotiations.  Because we fought hard, we were able to fend off House Republican efforts to cut hundreds of million of dollars from our schools and pass a fiscally responsible budget in an extremely difficult fiscal environment.

Again, it's great to be with you and now on to the questions.



Thank YOU for coming on RK to live blog (Lowell - 3/26/2008 3:04:15 PM)
I'm really happy to have you as my State Senator; keep up the great work, and happy blogging! :)


Peak oil (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:04:38 PM)
Thanks for mentioning Peak Oil.  For those of you who aren't so famliar with the concept, "Peak Oil" is a shorthand term for peak world production of oil.  We reached that milestone in the United States about 1970 and most countries have reached their year of peak production and are now in decline.  Increased production in some countries is being offset by declines in others.  Demand around the world continues to rise while the difficulty and cost of achieving new production also climbs.  There is also increased demand within oil-producing countries so we are likely to face "peak exports" before peak oil.  In short we are facing a liquid fuels crisis, some of which is reflected in today's high prices but which is likely to get worse fairly quickly.

It is clear that we need to prepare for this event.  The oil companies and the Bush administration push for more exploration but what we really need to do is CONSERVE and encourage the development of alternative and renewable forms of energy. The one thing that can really help is that we are currently so wasteful that there is a lot of room to reduce use of fossil fuels.

If you are interested in learning more about peak oil see the website for the Association for the Study of Peak Oil - USA at www.aspo-usa.com. (For full disclosure I should add that my husband, Tom Whipple, is the editor of the weekly Peak Oil Review published electronically by ASPO-USA.  He also produces a daily Peak Oil News and writes a weekly column on the subject in the Falls Church News Press.)



Smoking ban (TheGreenMiles - 3/25/2008 12:09:50 PM)
With Del. Dave Albo & friends once again having killed any bills to protect us from secondhand smoke at the state level, do communities have any options to take action on their own? The same Republicans who rail against big government cry Dillon Rule anytime a city or county tries to take action. Any tips for local officials and community activists looking to make headway on this issue?  


Smoking ban (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:10:24 PM)
I was proud to be the patron the the comprehensive bill that would have banned smoking in most public places that passed the Senate.  The Governor's bill to ban smoking in restaurants, patroned by Sen. Ralph Northam and Sen. Mamie Locke also passed the Senate as did a bill to allow localities to adopt local ordinances to ban smoking in restaurants in their jurisdictions. So of course it was disheartening to see all the bills fail on an unrecorded vote in a House of Delegates subcommittee.

There is nor authority, in our Dillon Rule state, for localities to ban smoking without enabling legislation.

Nevertheless, this is an issue that really resonates with the voters with very high percentages in favor of smoking bans in public places.  The dangers of secondhand smoke are well-known and I believe we will ultimately prevail.  



Transportation Funding (Eric - 3/25/2008 12:19:08 PM)
Sen. Whipple, thanks for join us.

My question is regarding transportation funding - or the lack thereof after the Va Supreme court decision and the repeal of the abusive fees.  What would be your ideal course of action and, given that the flat earth Republicans control the House, what is the most realistic solution we can hope for (if any)?



Transportation funding (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:19:45 PM)
The Virginia Senate has consistently fought for a statewide plan to secure the maintenance fund and regional funs for new projects.  We feel strongly that you can't do just one -- you have to do both.

According to VDOT, this year $388 million of highway construction funds will be diverted to maintenance and it only gets worse in the future. By 2015 the transfer out of construction will exceed $600 million

This diversion means that NoVa and Hampton Roads are losing over $200 million in construction funds this year alone and other regions of the Commonwealth are losing about $200 million as well.

By FY2016 we wouldn't even be able to provide the state match for Federal funding.

Republicans in he House of Delegates have proposed to address the portions of last year's HB3202 that were deemed to be unconstitutional by pushing off voting for taxes and fees to the localities, again failing to acknowledge that transportation is a state responsibility.  And they had no proposal for dealing with the maintenance shortfall.



Why do you think Chap Petersen's (Lowell - 3/25/2008 12:52:03 PM)
Clean Energy Future Act went nowhere this session?  Are people ignorant of the urgent need to slash greenhouse gas emissions 80%-90% over the next 2-3 decades?  Or, to be blunt, is it that too many of our elected officials are more concerned with pleasing big donors like Dominion Power?  Finally, do you believe there's been sufficient leadership at the gubernatorial level on this issue, as there's been in Maryland, Florida, California, Kansas, and many other states?  Thanks.


Clean Energy Future. (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:26:39 PM)
One reason that Chap's bill didn't go very far is that the General Assembly had enacted a voluntary Renewable Portfolio Standard only last Session.  Although voluntary, the utilities are complying with it thus far and I think the GA wanted to see how it would go before making changes.  There is often very little appetite for mandating changes and my bill of 2007 that would have mandated an RPS also did not pass. We do need to do more, but we have to recognize that Virginia tends to be incremental in its approach.  Governor Kaine's executive order re energy use by the state is quite sweeping, including mandating that all new state building be built to LEED standards.  The energy plan gives us a good start on reducing emissions.


Just to clarify (Lowell - 3/26/2008 3:55:51 PM)
Are you saying that Chap's bill is not needed? In my opinion i most definitely IS needed, given "peak oil," global warming, national security and all the other issues out there.  Frankly, a voluntary RPS isn't going to cut it if we plan on having the polar ice caps (and the polar bears, and humans) around a few more years.


Why did the Senate GOP bail on the Homestead Exemption? (James Martin - 3/25/2008 12:59:29 PM)
...and do you think it will pass next session?


Homestead exemption (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:31:51 PM)
I wish I knew what they were thinking!  The bill passed by 39-1 last year in the Senate and came out of the House unanimously this year, only to die in the Senate with a vote to refer it back to a committee that would not be meeting again.

Last year was an election year so a vote to reduce homeowner taxes was a popular one.  This year the business community came out strongly against it and some Senators complained about the wording (maybe they didn't read it last year?).

I'm not sure what the prospects are for next year.



Any chance (Teddy - 3/25/2008 1:16:46 PM)
of getting reformation of the painfully politicized re-districting method we use in Virginia? I mean, can the Republicans be made to understand that it would be in their own self-interest to pass a bill setting up a non-partisan redistricting system, as several other states have already done?


Redistricting (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:35:21 PM)
I supported Creigh Deeds redistricting bill that set up a nonpartisan commission to propose a redistricting plan after the next census.  

It's surprising to me that the Republicans don't support this approach.  I think it would be in their interests as the state becomes increasingly "blue".



With Bill Bolling's announcement (Lowell - 3/25/2008 1:36:10 PM)
that he will run for reelection as lieutenant governor and not run for governor, do you believe the Democrats should work something out where either Creigh Deeds or Brian Moran "drops down" to AG and lets the other one run for governor?  If that doesn't happen, do you think it will hurt Democrats, make no difference, or even help Democrats?  Thanks.


and Steve Shannon in that case? n/t (teacherken - 3/25/2008 11:56:20 PM)


2009 (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:40:33 PM)
I was quite surprised at Bolling's announcement.  Naturally they are spinning it that they will be in a strong position going into the statewide races if they don't have a primary.  I definitely think the jury is still out on that point.  Often a primary can really get a campaign organized and ready to go.

That said, we are fortunate to have such able candidates on our side and I'm feeling very good about the Democrats winning the statewide races next year.



Immigration (Lowell - 3/25/2008 2:07:30 PM)
There was a stark difference this year between the House and Senate on one issue more than any other one -- immigration.  How do you explain that, and are you pleased with the outcome (the Senate stopped almost all immigration-related bills coming out of the House)?


Immigration (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:46:20 PM)
We approached immigration this year focused on ensuring that those here illegally who commit serious crimes are brought to justice and deported.  We also worked on measures that would give localities the ability to enforce over-crowding ordinances. Senator Barker patroned two bills that dealt with the over-crowding that passed.

However, the House sent over several bills that we found to be too extreme and were able to defeat.  These bills were fiercely opposed by the legal immigrant community in Virginia, and rightly so.

We are committed to doing what's right and working to pass sensible and effective immigration reform.



Greetings (citizenindy - 3/25/2008 2:52:08 PM)
Start with the softball

What is the one bill you wish would have been passed

The real question

As Kaine famously repeatedly stated during his campaign for governor Trying to tax and pave our way out of traffic won't work. In your view what is the long-term solution for transportation.  (I am looking for more than the standard mass transit boiler plate talking point response)

Thanks in advance  



More than one question . . . (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:53:29 PM)
Before I go further, I can see that my answers have been rather long, so I will try to respond more briefly after this so I can get to as many questions as possible before I have to sign off.

Bill I wish had passed:  my bill to ban smoking in most public places.

Long-term solution for transportation -- changes in our driving habits!  And I'm disappointed you think transit amounts to a "boiler plate talking point response"  As former chair of the Metro Board, I really believe in transit and ride-sharing in all forms (e.g., carpools, vanpools, etc.).

And as former chair and member of the Arlington County Board, I have seen smart growth work in my own community.



Transportation Related to HOT Lanes (Matt H - 3/25/2008 2:58:26 PM)
Why is the state paying a private management company for lost revenue if more than 27% of HOT lane drivers access these lanes for free, by having 3 or more people in a vehicle?

Do you find it offensive that richer people should be able to get home earlier to spend time with their families than folks who can't afford $30 a day or more to be able to drive on our roads?



HOT Lanes (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 3:59:15 PM)
HOT lanes are in imperfect solution to the congestion we are experiencing and is a response occasioned by the state's unwillingness to adopt revenue sources that could fund needed transportation improvements.  The advantage is to get more capacity that can be used by buses and carpools or vanpools for free. The disadvantage, as you point out, is that some people will not have the means to access the lanes if they drive alone.  Of course, one hope is that the non-HOV lanes will be less crowded.


SB436, SB776, and SB476 (Nevis - 3/25/2008 6:24:46 PM)
Senator,

I'm a resident of your district and I would like to know why:

1.) You voted to pass SB 436 (Senator Vogal's locked container bill) yet when it came around for a VETO overide you voted no.  If it was good enough for your support the first time around, why wasn't it good enough the second?

2.) You voted for Senate Bill 776, which allows assistant Commonwealth's attorneys to carry concealed weapons without a permit, and without firearms training(40-Y 0-N), and voted against Senate Bill 476, which would allow concealed weapons to be carried into restaurants that may serve alcohol (24-Y 15-N) by CHP holders.

Why do you believe that assistant Commonwealths Attorneys (lawyers who work for the State) are more qualified to carry a concealed handgun (with NO training) into a Restaurant (VA does not have Bars) that may serve alcohol, than CHP holders who are required to have firearms training before they receive their permits?

I'd like to know your thinking on this.

Thank you.



thanks for you opposition to SB476 senator whipple! (notwaltertejada - 3/26/2008 1:26:42 AM)
i am also a resident of your district and am glad you have the foresight to see that guns and alcohol don't mix well. i think most residents in arlington would agree that the bill is a bad idea. does anyone else remember the hi-cue murder from a couple years ago?
thanks for voting the right way on this bill senator!


Which is right? (Nevis - 3/26/2008 8:31:09 AM)
If Senator Whipple voted correctly on SB476, how can she then be right on SB776? SB776 makes no provisions, nor does it place ANY limitations on WHERE or WHEN these newly exempt people may carry.

For example - 18.2-308 (B) says that anyone listed under the "B" section is completely exempt from the concealed carry law, EXCEPT for J1, which just says you can't carry concealed while DRUNK.   The Commonwealth Attorneys were added as a new entry "(B) 9" and are thus allowed to  
carry a concealed handgun in restaurants and drink, amongst other things.

Can't be right on both.



A stabbing (Nevis - 3/26/2008 9:53:37 AM)
by Asian gang members.  2001.

Hi - Cue is now Dog Paw and Cat Claw University Doggie day care.

BTW - I guess it bears repeating so that the above questions are in context:

It is LEGAL to Open Carry a Firearm into a Reastaurant/Bar so long as you do not consume alcohol.  That is the law and it is State wide.



Gun laws (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 4:06:12 PM)
I really don't think that guns in bars and restaurants are a good idea. Furthermore, I think that localities should have a lot more say about what is appropriate in their own communities.  I tend to follow the advice of law enforcement in this arena and that is why I changed my vote on Senator Vogel's bill -- they felt very strongly that passage of the bill would put them at more risk.


The State Police (Nevis - 3/26/2008 4:07:21 PM)
Testified in committee thast they had no position on this.

to which LE agency do you refer?



James Walkinshaw (Ben - 3/26/2008 9:11:41 AM)
Has been telling people in Prince William County that Leslie Byrne lost her State Senate seat to you.

I was under the impression the Republicans drew Leslie in with you, and she stepped aside since a large majority of the district had been yours before redistricting.

Would you like to clarify this?



Not True (JamesWalkinshaw - 3/26/2008 3:04:17 PM)
Ben,

I've said nothing of the sort.  I'm not sure where you heard this.

Frankly, I'm not sure people in PW care what happened to Mrs. Byrne's seat in '03 and wouldn't spend time discussing it.



What happened to Leslie's seat (Ben - 3/26/2008 3:34:18 PM)
Was Republicans removed her from it and created an open seat in another part of Fairfax.

And under Gerry's "coattails" for Chairman the open seat went Republican.



Senate Seat (SenatorWhipple - 3/26/2008 4:11:44 PM)
The last part of your question is the right answer -- the Republicans deliberately put Leslie in the 31st district that was predominantly the district in which I was the incumbent.

THANKS AGAIN for inviting me to participate in this live blog.  My schedule precludes me from staying on any longer.

MMW



Feel free to come back later (Lowell - 3/26/2008 4:15:44 PM)
if you'd like and comment some more. Also, you're welcome to live blog here anytime.  Thanks again.


Wise County Coal Plant (Eric - 3/26/2008 2:24:03 PM)
What is your position on Dominion's proposed Wise County Coal plant?

And, if you are against it, will you personally lobby Governor Kaine to change his pro-coal position?



I second that motion. (Lowell - 3/26/2008 2:59:21 PM)
Gov. Kaine's position on the Wise County coal-fired plant is, with all due respect to this blog's namesake, dead wrong (environmentally, economically, morally, you name it).


Darn (TheGreenMiles - 3/26/2008 5:10:35 PM)
Really wish Sen. Whipple could have gotten to this one. Sorry her schedule stopped her just short.


Yeah, (Eric - 3/26/2008 5:57:13 PM)
it was an unfortunately place to run out of time.

Perhaps she'll be good enough to come back and answer during some free time in her schedule the next few days.



On a local note (Lowell - 3/26/2008 3:07:15 PM)
Any favorites for school board in Arlington?


Power 2 Change (phillip123 - 3/26/2008 3:11:36 PM)
As the diary below discusses a major campaign is being launched nation wide including here in Virginia.  Do you support the campaign and do you think it will help to build support for initiatives such as Chap Petersen's clean energy initiative?


Just to elaborate a bit... (Lowell - 3/26/2008 3:14:53 PM)
The campaign has five core policies to create the clean energy future:

   *20% renewable electricity by 2020

   *"Vastly improve energy efficiency measures in ... offices and facilities" of "businesses, manufacturers, and the auto industry" both via incentives and requirements

   *Education campaigns to "encourage the public to improve energy efficiency"; incentives for home renewable energy and energy efficiency;  and incentives for reduced driving or hybrid vehicles

   *Remove subsidies from the oil industry to use the funds for renewable energy

   *Green jobs: "Train a clean energy workforce: construction workers who know how to retrofit an older building, electricians who know to install energy efficient heating and cooling systems and solar panels, plant workers who know how to make wind turbine components and hybrid cars - and many more."



Metro to Dulles (Lowell - 3/26/2008 3:13:33 PM)
Do you know when, if ever, the Kaine administration is going to admit that the FTA will not fund Tysons Rail under the current (Bush) administration?  Why are they STILL assuming that everything's OK with this project, when it obviously isn't. And why are they sticking to the no-bid Bechtel deal, without a smart-growth-friendly tunnel in Tysons, instead of moving to do this thing right?  I'm baffled.


LG in '09 (MikeSizemore - 3/26/2008 3:14:50 PM)
While the Democrats do have 2 big names gunning for the top spot in 2009, the bench seems to be fairly limited downticket, especially at the Lieutenant Governor position. One name that has been frequently brought up (on this blog as well) is that of Jon Bonwerbank, businessman and Russell County Board of Supervisors Member. I know that Jon is very popular in Southwest, Virginia, and has been making the rounds in other parts of the state, including your region of Northern Va. I am curious to know your opinions of Jon; whether or not you have had the chance to meet him and what not, as well as your opinion of his candidacy, since he would potentially stand to gavel in your body of the legislature in Richmond.

Thank you for taking the time to answer our questions and keep up the good work!