More Jobs for Less Money: Why Can't We Get Energy Projects Like That?

By: TheGreenMiles
Published On: 2/25/2008 9:37:42 AM

Check out this huge new solar project just announced for Arizona:
Abengoa Solar, which has plants in Spain, northern Africa and other parts of the U.S., could begin construction as early as next year on the 280-megawatt plant in Gila Bend -- a small, dusty town 50 miles southeast of Phoenix. [...]

Arizona regulators are requiring utilities to get 15 percent of their electricity from renewable sources by 2025, with annual increases of roughly 1 percent.

So if Arizona can become "the Persian Gulf of solar energy" as Gov. Janet Napolitano predicts, why can't Virginia do the same with its wind power potential? Because our elected officials have repeatedly rejected mandatory clean energy standards, so Virginia is losing out on our share of the clean energy boom - billions in investment and tens of thousands of jobs nationwide.

Instead, our governor and General Assembly are clinging to coal, trying to spend $1.8 billion on a coal-fired power plant in Wise County to bring 800 construction jobs and about 50 permanent full-time jobs. Meanwhile, the Arizona solar plant will not only cost about half as much, it'll create twice as many construction jobs and 85 full-time jobs.

Please tell Gov. Kaine right now that it's not too late to do the right thing.


Comments



I should point out... (ericy - 2/25/2008 11:38:52 AM)

If you look at the wind maps for the state of Virginia:

http://www.eere.energy.gov/win...

that most of Virginia's wind potential is offshore.  For onshore sites, the wind either isn't strong enough, or isn't regular enough.



its the market (Alter of Freedom - 2/25/2008 12:22:47 PM)
as I am sure you know the market for exporting coal is booming right now, especially to China and South Africa requiring more and more coal for its manufacturing capabilities, especially the steel industry we all but handed to the Chinese in the last twenty years. As long as exports of coal are rising then politicans will be slow to wrap their arms around solar power or wind farms. While I agree on the jobs point, if you want to address jobs why not bring back a federal incentive for America to re-start or jumpstart our manufacturing base and steel industry by authorizing an infrastrcuture rehabilitation agenda to not only update our infrastructure but also put Amercians to work by taking back our manufacturing economy. It may not be the best thing (coal) for the environment when compared to solar/wind power, but then are we willing to put our environmental policy ahead of any program or agenda that seeks to rebuild America, stimulate the economy,create jobs, maybe address our road/bridge issues in the fashion of FDR. Hard question I know.


Demand question (tx2vadem - 2/25/2008 1:27:54 PM)
So, if coal exports are rising, why would we want to tie up those coal resources in supplying a coal fired power plant?  Demand we know is rising primarily due to China and at some point India will have an effect.  I think since economic growth is so high in both of those places, the increased demand will have a greater effect on prices as supply won't be as quick to catch up.  That being the case, the higher cost of fuel for the power plant will be passed on to consumers through rate-making.  So, in the end, it may not be cheaper for this power.


In the end it may not be about "cheaper" (Alter of Freedom - 2/25/2008 2:01:10 PM)
From a political perspective which is what I was addressing it certainly may have little to do with whether its "cheaper" or not I am afraid. We sometimes look at these things in abox, I know I do at times, but politicans have this nasty little ability to paint things with broad strokes and the weight of any impact with regard to trade in this area will surely be pitched to them be the lobbyists to oppose anything that might curb coal production for distribution.
In the end in terms of the rise in coal demand WE have ourselves to blame. The economies of China and India are direct beneficiaries to OUR consumption of their exports. We get an unfair dose of the foriegn oil rhetoric against the Middle East while we get more oil from the Western Hemisphere because its politcially fashionable to do so while every major contender for the Presidency backs off of talking about China. Even if we could manage to get things moving to address the environment in a sound way, does any of us actually believe we will ever get the Chinese to clean up its act while in trade talks. It hard to demand much from your banker when he holds all the notes against you.


Small, dusty town? (Teddy - 2/25/2008 2:06:33 PM)
Gila Bend thanks you, I'm sure, for that characterization. When I attended the U of A in Tucson, there were cotton farmers making a bundle in that town, irrigated cotton, of course, heavily subsidized by the federal government as well... which tended to keep Gila Bend green in another way.

The thing about solar or wind plants is, they require little water to run (only water to fabricate the initial panels or windmills) and so this is another good thing for Arizona, which, like Nevada, has drawn down its aquifer and the Colorado River about as far as possible, and the state is desperate for water. Looks like another Democratic Governor (Napolitano) has a keen eye for the future; the political dynamics are undoubtedly very different for her than for Kaine.  



Thank AP (TheGreenMiles - 2/25/2008 3:15:59 PM)
That was the AP's characterization of Gila Bend, not mine. For the record, The Green Miles has never been there but is sure it is a rustic town with a rich history.

Don't forget how water shortages are affecting the nuclear industry, as well.



if there is a water shortage maybe people ought to act like it (Alter of Freedom - 2/25/2008 5:00:56 PM)
I have seen the reports of growing water shortage concerns, especially in areas now going after the ethanol market in the midwest but it begs the question how can we get serious about water shortage as an issue when the fasting growing consumer drink segment after the energy drink craze is the bottled water market now in the billions of dollars? Scary is'nt it.


Cotton in the Desert! (Eric - 2/25/2008 4:38:40 PM)
I've seen it down there as well.  Un-freakin-believable.