Responsible Company Gets Responsibler: Whole Foods Bags the Plastic

By: TheGreenMiles
Published On: 2/1/2008 10:56:38 AM

Big news recently in the grocery business:

The Whole Foods Market chain said Tuesday that it would stop offering plastic grocery bags, giving customers instead a choice between recycled paper or reusable bags.

A rising number of governments and retailers are banning plastic bags, or discouraging their use, because of concerns about their environmental impact. San Francisco banned plastic bags last year unless they are of a type that breaks down easily. China announced a crackdown on plastic bags a few weeks ago, while other governments, including New York City’s, are making sure retailers offer plastic bag recycling.

Plastic bags are slightly better than paper from a global warming point of view. But at least paper bags biodegrade if they're not disposed of properly. Misplaced plastic bags have contributed to a swirling plastic trash vortex the size of Texas out in the middle of the Pacific Ocean.

The bag effort is far from Whole Foods' only green initiative:

One legit criticism of Whole Foods has come over its anti-union stances

Not all of us have a Whole Foods nearby. Meanwhile, The Green Miles lives across the street from a Harris Teeter, so firing up the car to drive to Whole Foods would negate the environmental benefits.

But do you shop green? A recent survey says that while Americans like those ideas in theory, they don't actually practice those habits. 

Do you buy organic products? Use a reusable grocery bag? Support green businesses?

Comments



plastic bags (martha - 2/1/2008 1:02:19 PM)
I have mentioned this on this blog before but my daughter is in HR w/ Kroger Mid-Atlantic corp. I fussed at her about Whole Foods and the bag thing.

This is what she said:

ANYTIME enough customers complain and recommend something to Kroger it reaches the higher levels. SO complain!!

She went to Arizona this fall and brought me bag some really nice re-usable FRYS bags. They look small but hold a ton of groceries!

I am getting better about taking my own bags...still not great but getting better.I have to remember to take them back out to the car after unloading.

If you shop at any Kroger take your own bags and mention the whole plastic bag issue! Also: Kroger is a Union Shop!!!! I don't think there are any Kroger stores in NOVA but they are located  in pretty much the rest of the state.



Cool (TheGreenMiles - 2/1/2008 1:11:35 PM)
Who knew we had a Kroger booster on the blog?  :)

I agree that with reusable bags it takes a while to get to the point where you make a habit of bringing them every time. But then again, once you do, it's so nice not to be buried under an avalanche of bags every time you open the cabinet under the sink!



The Deal Breaker (AnonymousIsAWoman - 2/1/2008 2:03:56 PM)
My local Giant recently had a drive to encourage people to use the recycleable cloth bags; they even gave them away free with a coupon.  And they will give paper bags to anybody who asks - my husband and I do.

Whole Foods, Harris Teeter and any of the other "hip" environmentally friendly stores that seek to appeal to upper middle class consumers by being green but, who neglect their own employees, won't get my business.

There's a vast difference between a business that truly treats its employees so well that the employees don't want a union, don't organize for one and wouldn't vote one in and a company that has to actively engage in union busting, as Whole Foods did.

I also am opposed to the libertarian philosophy of Whole Foods owner, which economically means no regulation, regardless of how sensible; no miniumum wage; total free market; and the government is always the problem - sound like any party you know?

I want to shop green but that's a deal breaker for me.



My favorite cost-cutter ... (TheGreenMiles - 2/1/2008 2:21:30 PM)
... is the self-checkout stations. Or as I like to call them, The Things I Plot To Smash Into a Million Pieces When No One Is Looking. Trying to use one is the most infuriating experience this side of the DMV.


Kroger (martha - 2/1/2008 3:08:00 PM)
Their union isn't strong but at least they have one. The employees had very affordable health care until recently they paid very little. The cost has gone up some but the union did its best to protect the workers.

They make Earth's Best organic baby foods available and affordable, employ their own dietician who publishes heart and cancer healthy tips and they make EC available and their pharmacists don't prevent anyone from obtaining it. If a pharmacist is there who doesn't believe in EC there is always another option available for the customer.

Kroger is not the best grocery store but it's way better than Wal Mart and is a Fortune 50 company !



I've used Giant's cloth bags for a year or more now (Dennis Coyle - 2/1/2008 7:03:12 PM)
They're only 99 cents and two of them hold at least as much as 6 or 8 plastic bags. I have 6 of the bags that live in the trunk of my car. Usually have 2 in the condo since I can walk to Giant, tho I do stop with the car if I'm on my way home. And carrying two cloth bags is much easier than 6 or 8 plastic.

The only reason I used to hoard the plastic bags was for scooping the cats' litter box. With the loss of the plastic bags, I bought a small trash can (with a tight cover) we keep next to the litter box. So even scooping is easier now. Win win situation.

Giant also gives a 3 cent rebate every time you use the cloth bag. As much as I shop, the bags end up essentially free. But at less than a buck, I've used them for other things and replaced 'em. (most of our Xmas decorations are in storage in 2 Giant bags now instead of replacing the old card board boxes.)



no Giants.... (martha - 2/1/2008 7:13:51 PM)
in Lynchburg.

We only have Food Kitty and Kroger and the local farmer's market!



canvass bag (Newport News Dem - 2/2/2008 12:35:46 PM)
I take a canvas bag to the store and use it in lieu of paper or plastic.

It is fun to say "neither" when asked by the clerk!



Clerks love bags (TheGreenMiles - 2/2/2008 12:43:55 PM)
The baggers have been so trained to put everything in plastic bags you practically have to beg them not to. Last night The Green Girlfriend and I went to Harris Teeter to grab a few things -- kitty litter, a couple of cases of soda, and some cookies. The clerk tried to put the bag of kitty litter in a bag. I said, "It's OK, we don't need any bags." Then he tried to stick the cookies in a bag! This time The Green Girlfriend said, "I can handle the cookies on my own."  


Ireland's plastic bag tax (TheGreenMiles - 2/2/2008 1:01:48 PM)
From today's NYTimes:
In 2002, Ireland passed a tax on plastic bags; customers who want them must now pay 33 cents per bag at the register. There was an advertising awareness campaign. And then something happened that was bigger than the sum of these parts.

Within weeks, plastic bag use dropped 94 percent. Within a year, nearly everyone had bought reusable cloth bags, keeping them in offices and in the backs of cars. Plastic bags were not outlawed, but carrying them became socially unacceptable - on a par with wearing a fur coat or not cleaning up after one's dog.



I haven't used a plastic bag (Lowell - 2/2/2008 1:05:06 PM)
at the grocery store in months.  I bought a few reusable bags for 99 cents each and always have a couple in the car. As an added bonus, I get money back for using the reusable bags...not a lot, but at least it pays for the bags in a few months.