State Action (or not) on Global Warming
By: Lowell
Published On: 11/25/2007 8:04:01 PM
While George W. Bush is doing nothing on global warming, states are increasingly starting to take action. Here are some interesting maps, courtesy of the Pew Center on Global Climate Change, which illustrate clearly where things are going on. The first map, to the left, represents "States with Greenhouse Gas Emissions Targets." One state that jumps out at me is Florida, which has been governed by Republicans for some time now:
On July 13, 2007, Florida Governor Charlie Crist issued Executive Order 07-127, which established statewide GHG emission reduction targets of 2000 levels by 2017, 1990 levels by 2025, and 80 percent below 1990 levels by 2050.
Also, the Republican governor of California, Ah-nuld Schwarzenegger, "signed the Global Warming Solutions Act, AB 32, which capped the state's GHG emissions at 1990 levels by 2020."
See the "flip" for more maps, and note that most of them do NOT include Virginia. That obviously needs to change.
This map is particularly interesting. Note that just about every state outside of the South is a member of a regional climate change initiative. This includes "red" states like Idaho, Montana, Nebraska and South Dakota. Again, where's Virginia?
There's a long way to go in this area: "States with a Carbon Cap or Offset Requirement for Power Plants." Good luck getting that one past Dominion Power, which is so powerful in Virginia that it writes its OWN regulation bill! Unbelievable.
Finally, a map that includes Virginia, thanks to "'Virginia Energy Plan,' completed in 2007." The only problem is, this plan doesn't even come close to the 80% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions that scientists say is necessary to avert climatic disaster. Instead, the plan has Virginia's greenhouse gas emissions back at 1990 levels by 2025. That's a start, but again, it's not even close to what's needed.
Here's a key map, depicting "States with Renewable Portfolio Standards." On the bright side, Virginia has a renewable portfolio standard. On the FAR-less-than-bright side, Virginia's standard is pathetic (12% of 2007 sales by 2022 - wow!) and also purely voluntary on the part of utilities. In other words, it's almost worse than nothing.
In sum, many states are taking action to combat global warming. Unfortunately, by and large, Virginia isn't one of them.
Comments
would you cross-post this at big orange? (teacherken - 11/25/2007 9:17:30 PM)
we have a group of environmentalists, and if you post this, or something similar (not specifically focused on Virginia) either Siegel or I could put out the word to the group and get it quite a bit of visibility
Two minor problems. (Lowell - 11/25/2007 9:58:09 PM)
1. This is focused on Virginia and would have to be tweaked.
2. The images would all have to be uploaded to Flickr or another service that Daily Kos accepts.
Time to catch up! (Kindler - 11/25/2007 10:17:02 PM)
Thanks for the maps, Lowell -- very enlightening, and it shows pretty damn clearly that Virginia needs to start catching up quickly. I personally think we should explore joining the Northeast's Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative.
With Gov. Kaine willing to take only baby steps so far, we need the new Democratic Senate to push the climate issue hard. Of course, we do have a few folks who campaigned hard on environmental issues in the last election -- Chap, Margi, can we count on you to lead Virginia to a carbon-neutral future?
Is it Dominion Power (Teddy - 11/25/2007 10:21:03 PM)
that's holding Virginia back? We have had two Democratic Governors in a row, so it may be the anti-science hostility of the conservative Republicans who dominate the Assembly---- or not. Does anyone know why we lag so terribly? Can't be the coal mines, other states with coal mines have stepped up to the plate.
And what exactly does it mean if a state is not a member of a regional group, but is An Observer?
Dominion has a great deal of "power" (Lowell - 11/25/2007 10:26:57 PM)
in more ways than one. Their slogan says "It All Starts Here," but what I really think they mean to say is that Virginia's laws on energy and the environment all start (and end) with them. What we need is strong leadership that will either persuade Dominion to work to solve common problems, or get tough with them.
On the "observer" status, I think it means that the state hasn't completely bought into the group's goals, but they want to keep an eye what's going on. I'm sure it varies state by state as to what the exact motivations are.
Dominion & coal rule Virginia (TheGreenMiles - 11/25/2007 11:14:08 PM)
Even though coal only provides a few thousand jobs in Virginia, legislators are terrified of doing anything to stop or even slow the use of coal. A new coal-fired power plant is planned for Wise County, which would dramatically increase Virginia's carbon emissions.
And much as I'd like to put all the blame on Republicans, Democrats have so far been afraid to step up to the plate. Look at Gov. Kaine's energy plan -- it doesn't even cut carbon emissions from current levels, only hoping to slow the growth of emissions.
Can't disagree with you there. (Lowell - 11/25/2007 11:20:08 PM)
It's time for Democrats to "step up to the plate," as you say. There's no more time to waste, and no more room for excuses on this one. Half measures and "greenwashing" don't count either. Nor do declarations without substantive follow through.
The Dominion of Dominion (Kindler - 11/26/2007 11:38:46 PM)
Hey Teddy, perfect example of Dominion's
power was the bill Mary Margaret Whipple sponsored last session requiring a certain amount of Virginia's electricity to come from renewable energy. Dominion's lobbyists stepped in and said, fine, we'll accept this -- as long as it's completely voluntary!
And so it goes in the great state of Virginia...